
Suppose that one day everyone on the planet woke up in a state of global peace. How would we recognise it? Our ability to recognise it would depend on what we think peace is, on how we define it, and subsequently on how we measure it.
Conflicting concepts
Peace researchers devote their working lives to the question: “what is peace?”. Despite this, they do not seem to agree on what a comprehensive definition of peace could be.
In Conflicting Concepts of Peace in Contemporary Peace Studies, L. Gunnar Johnson wrote in 1976, “The image of peace in peace studies is blurred as a result of conflicting definitions held by researchers”. He observed that “researchers are studying different problems and pursuing divergent goals, all under the banner of ‘peace’” (p. 7).
In 2004, Royce Anderson pointed out what this means for measuring peace. With “no consensus on a conceptually clear definition”, researchers lack a common basis for deciding what to count as evidence of peace.
In 2024, Boulanger Martel and colleagues identified 61 concepts of peace in around 180 English-language scholarly works published from 1969 to 2022.
Why do definitions differ?
Having several definitions for a term can be useful. Those 61 concepts approach peace from many angles. Some look for an end to violence, some for fair institutions, some for how people get through ordinary days, and some for the quality of relationships.
One definition of peace makes the cessation of attacks easier to study. Another draws attention to how people treat one another in daily life. But a count of attacks and an account of how neighbours settle a dispute do not by themselves show what those findings have in common at their roots.
As things are now, peace researchers could look at the same world on the same morning and disagree about whether it was at peace.
What would we look for?
Four examples, beginning with a precursor to the period covered by the review, show how differently researchers might read that same morning.
Jane Addams: nurturing human life
Decades before Johan Galtung, often called the father of peace studies, wrote about positive and negative peace, Jane Addams described peace in Newer Ideals of Peace as “the unfolding of world-wide processes making for the nurture of human life”. Addams was envisioning what peace could become under what she called enlightened industrialism.
Johan Galtung: negative and positive peace
In 1964, Galtung drew a distinction between “negative peace” and “positive peace”. In 1969, he drew the distinction in terms of two kinds of violence, personal and structural. In 1990, he added a third, cultural violence.
He described negative peace as the “absence of personal violence” and he described positive peace as the “absence of structural violence”. Structural violence is harm that comes from the way society is organised.
If we were examining peace through Galtung’s lens, waking up in a state of peace, the first thing we would check would be whether anyone was still being attacked. The second thing would be to look for evidence of structural violence. A family could wake up to no attacks at all and still be locked out of their home by rules that favoured other families.
Roger Mac Ginty: everyday peace
Roger Mac Ginty defines everyday peace as “the methods that individuals and groups use to navigate their way through life in deeply divided societies”. His definition points to how people deal with one another in ordinary moments.
A shopkeeper who lets a provocative remark pass may keep a quarrel from escalating. That can matter to both people. It lets them get on with the day’s work and makes it easier to deal with each other again tomorrow. But if the shopkeeper stays quiet for fear of being threatened, the quarrel can end calmly while the threat still limits what the shopkeeper feels safe saying. The silence can still be an everyday peace strategy in Mac Ginty’s sense, even though the threat remains.
Söderström, Åkebo and Jarstad: peaceful relationships
Söderström, Åkebo and Jarstad say that a peaceful relationship involves “deliberation, non-domination, and cooperation”. The parties also “recognize and trust each other” and understand their relationship as one between legitimate counterparts or friends.
On that world-wide peaceful morning, two neighbouring communities might still disagree over how to share a river. Both can explain what they need, neither can impose a decision, and together they work out an arrangement.
They accept that both communities have a right to the water and trust each other enough to keep to the arrangement. They can do all of that while still disagreeing about how the water ought to be shared.
What do these definitions have in common?
These accounts can seem to describe different things. But they have a lot in common. Perhaps, they are more like the blind men in the old parable, each touching a different part of an elephant: one feels the trunk, another a leg, another the tail, and each describes the whole animal from the part in front of them.
IGP has set out to describe the whole animal.
In The Sovereignty of Sentience, published in the Journal on the Use of Force and International Law, its Founding Director, Anders Reagan, introduces a comprehensive theory for defining, measuring and building peace. Building on a 2023 paper on the foundations of peace research, the article considers whether all 61 concepts of peace describe different aspects of the same thing: how sentient subjects affect one another’s wellbeing through relationality.
